Sun Prairie Housing Market: September 2026 Sales

What did homes sell for in the Sun Prairie area during September 2026? The supplied MLS sales reports show 57 single-family home sales and 10 condo sales, totaling approximately $34.93 million in closed sales.

Single-family sale prices ranged from $300,000 to $1.85 million, while condos sold from $207,000 to $395,000. That wide range makes it helpful to look beyond one headline number and examine each property type separately.

Here’s a closer look at September’s results and how buyers and sellers can use them.

September 2026 Sales at a Glance

The median is the middle sale price when sales are sorted from lowest to highest. The average incorporates every sale, so particularly expensive properties can pull it upward. Both figures are useful, but neither replaces a comparison with homes similar to yours.

Single-Family Homes: A $519,900 Median Sale Price

The 57 single-family sales in September had an average price of $560,241 and a median of $519,900.

Of those closings, 26 homes—approximately 46%—sold for less than $500,000. Another 24 sold from $500,000 to just under $700,000, and seven sold for $700,000 or more.

That distribution gives buyers and sellers more context than the average alone. September’s report includes smaller homes, larger homes, and properties in several municipalities, all contributing to the overall results.

A few examples illustrate the range:

• 137 South Street, Sun Prairie: $300,000; 3 bedrooms and 1,296 finished square feet.
• 723 Kelly Street, Sun Prairie: $418,000; 4 bedrooms and 1,834 finished square feet.
• 1232 Orchid Petal Drive, Sun Prairie: $470,000; 3 bedrooms and 1,836 finished square feet.
• 2019 Leopold Way, Sun Prairie: $519,900; 3 bedrooms and 1,876 finished square feet.
• 933 Chalfont Drive, Sun Prairie: $670,000; 4 bedrooms and 3,881 finished square feet.
• 1421 Stonehaven Drive, Sun Prairie: $739,900; 3 bedrooms and 2,277 finished square feet.

These are reference points rather than interchangeable comparisons. Size, condition, age, location, lot, layout, and finishes all matter when evaluating a particular home.

How the Highest Sale Affects the Average

The highest single-family sale in the report was 6837 Elder Lane in the Town of Bristol at $1,850,000.

Including that sale, the average single-family price was $560,241. Excluding it, the average of the remaining 56 sales was approximately $537,210. The full report’s median was $519,900.

The $1.85 million closing belongs in the overall results, but its effect illustrates why I look at the median and individual comparable sales alongside the average. A broad market average can be influenced by properties that have little in common with the home you want to buy or sell.

Sun Prairie Area Condos: A $288,250 Median Sale Price

September’s 10 condo sales had an average price of $299,840 and a median of $288,250. Prices ranged from $207,000 to $395,000.

Six of the 10 condos sold for less than $300,000. Finished living space ranged from 1,017 to 2,276 square feet, showing that the report includes a variety of sizes and layouts.

Examples include:

• 143 Talon Place, Sun Prairie: $207,000; 2 bedrooms and 1,017 finished square feet.
• 567 Kelvington Drive, Unit 1, Sun Prairie: $265,000; 2 bedrooms and 1,076 finished square feet.
• 3064 Triumph Drive, Unit 3, Sun Prairie: $280,000; 3 bedrooms and 1,728 finished square feet.
• 1155 Liberty Boulevard, Unit 34, Sun Prairie: $324,900; 3 bedrooms and 2,222 finished square feet.
• 737 Clarmar Drive, Sun Prairie: $370,000; 3 bedrooms and 2,276 finished square feet.
• 3056 Edmonton Drive, Sun Prairie: $395,000; 2 bedrooms and 2,179 finished square feet.

The condo median was $231,650 lower than the single-family median for the properties that closed this month. That difference may help buyers frame a search, but it does not measure the price difference between otherwise equivalent properties.

When comparing condos, buyers should also review association fees, maintenance responsibilities, rules, and what those fees cover. Those details affect both the monthly budget and how a property fits your needs.

What September’s Sales Mean for Sellers

If you’re considering selling in Sun Prairie, these closings offer useful recent evidence of what buyers paid. The next step is identifying which sales actually resemble your property.

A smaller established home, a larger newer home, and a condo can each have different competition. Pricing starts with relevant comparable sales and then considers homes currently available and properties with accepted offers.

At Matt Deadman Homes, Jenn and I help sellers connect the data to their own property. We consider the features buyers will compare, how the home presents, and the competing choices they have when it reaches the market.

The supplied reports do not include days on market, original asking prices, or concessions. These results therefore do not establish how quickly homes sold, whether buyers paid above asking price, or how much sellers negotiated. Without comparable prior-period data, they also do not establish whether prices rose or fell.

What September’s Sales Mean for Buyers

September’s completed sales show buyers purchasing homes across a broad range of prices. Condos closed from $207,000 to $395,000, while single-family sales started at $300,000.

These properties have already sold, so the figures are historical reference points rather than a list of current options. Still, they can help you evaluate asking prices and understand which property types may fit your budget.

Whether you’re purchasing your first home, looking for more space, or exploring condo living, a focused comparison is more useful than relying on the overall average. We can look at recent sales with similar features and compare them with the homes available today.

Planning a Move in Sun Prairie?

Jenn and I work with buyers and sellers in Sun Prairie and surrounding Dane County communities. Our goal at Matt Deadman Homes is to make the numbers understandable and help you apply them to your own plans.

If you’d like a closer look at your home’s potential value or what your budget could buy in the Sun Prairie area, contact us through mattdeadmanhomes.com. We’d be happy to walk through the local comparisons with you.

Source: Supplied MLS reports identified as September 2026 Sun Prairie condo and single-family sales. Calculations use the displayed prices; averages are rounded to the nearest dollar. The reports include properties in the City and Town of Sun Prairie as well as Madison, Bristol, and Burke, so totals describe the supplied Sun Prairie-area search rather than only the City of Sun Prairie. School attendance boundaries should be verified for any individual property. Monthly figures reflect the mix of properties that closed and do not determine the value of an individual home.